The rule that matters most: in state civil service, the job’s minimum qualifications decide whether you can apply, and many classifications let experience substitute for education year for year. If a class specification says “graduation from a four-year college, or four years of relevant experience,” then four years of work counts exactly the same as a diploma for getting onto the list. Read the substitution language before you skip a posting that mentions a degree.
Several states have gone further and removed degree requirements from most job classes outright. Pennsylvania’s governor announced in January 2023, through Executive Order 2023-03, that 92 percent of state government jobs, about 65,000 positions, do not require a four-year degree. Maryland made a similar move in 2022, and other states followed. Even in states that have not changed policy, the entry-level classes below are commonly open to applicants with a high school diploma.
How substitution clauses work
State jobs are organized into classifications, each with a written class specification. The minimum qualifications section usually reads one of three ways:
- No degree mentioned: high school diploma or GED plus some experience, or no experience at all for trainee levels.
- Degree or equivalent experience: education and experience are interchangeable, often at a set ratio such as one year of experience for each year of college.
- Degree required by law: licensed professions such as nursing, engineering or law, where the requirement comes from statute or licensing boards and cannot be waived.
Only the third type truly shuts out applicants without a degree. Our guide on how to read a government job posting shows where to find this language on a typical announcement.
Entry classifications compared
| Classification family | Typical minimum | What counts as experience | Usual next step up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Office assistant, clerk, administrative support | High school diploma; typing or office experience sometimes required | Any clerical, reception or data entry work | Senior clerk, administrative assistant, office manager |
| Customer service or eligibility representative | Diploma plus public contact experience | Retail, call center, banking teller work | Eligibility specialist, lead worker |
| Motor vehicle or licensing services | Diploma; cash handling experience helpful | Cashier, front-desk or service counter work | Senior technician, office supervisor |
| Correctional officer | Diploma, minimum age, academy after hire | Often none required | Sergeant and specialized posts |
| Highway or facilities maintenance | Diploma; driver’s license, often a CDL | Construction, landscaping, equipment operation | Equipment operator, crew supervisor |
| IT help desk or technician | Varies; often experience or certification in place of a degree | Desktop support, help desk, certifications | Systems or network analyst |
The titles change from state to state, but these families exist almost everywhere. The DMV row has its own detailed guide: state DMV clerk jobs.
Writing experience so it counts
When experience replaces education, the HR analyst must be able to verify it from your application. That means:
- Exact dates (month and year) for each job, so the analyst can add up the time.
- Hours per week, because part-time experience is often prorated. Twenty hours a week for a year may count as six months.
- Duties that match the class specification’s wording. If the spec asks for “experience processing applications for benefits or licenses,” describe your work in those terms if it honestly fits.
- Volunteer work, when the posting says it counts. Many state systems accept it if documented.
A vague line like “customer service, 2019-2023” may be scored as less experience than you really have. Spell it out.
Take a hypothetical applicant who worked three years as a bank teller, 40 hours a week, and one year as a part-time school office aide at 20 hours a week. Under a one-for-one substitution rule with part-time time prorated, that adds up to three and a half years of qualifying experience. If the class specification asks for “a bachelor’s degree or four years of experience in public contact and records work,” this applicant falls six months short today, but would qualify after half a year more of full-time work. Running that math yourself before applying saves you from a disqualification notice.
Where to look
Each state runs its own job portal, and some let you filter by education level. Pennsylvania, for example, launched a search tool after its 2023 order that filters for jobs without a four-year degree requirement. Our roundup of state government job portals lists where to start in each state.
Also check whether your state uses continuous testing or open lists for entry classes. Clerical and correctional classes are often open year-round, which means you can get on the list now and be considered whenever vacancies occur.
Frequently asked questions
Will I be paid less without a degree?
Generally no, for the same classification. State pay is attached to the job class and step, not to your education. A few classes pay an education differential, but that is the exception.
Can I be promoted without a degree?
In many systems, yes. Promotional classes often accept experience in the lower class as qualifying. Some supervisory or professional classes still require degrees, so check the specification for the job you eventually want.
Does a certificate or trade school count?
Often it counts as partial education or as meeting a specific requirement, such as an IT certification for a technician class. The class specification or posting will say how it is credited.
What if the posting says a degree is “preferred”?
Preferred qualifications are not minimums. If you meet the minimums, you can apply. Preferences may affect ranking or interview selection, so strengthen other parts of your application.
Putting it into practice
Pick two or three classification families from the table that fit your background. Find their class specifications on your state’s HR site and read the minimum qualifications line by line, including any substitution clause. Then rewrite your work history with exact dates, hours and duties that match that wording, and apply to every open list you qualify for.



